|
1. ATO submission on tax haven banks released
On 17 July 2008, the ATO provided a submission, on tax haven banks and US tax compliance, to the US Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Government Affairs. The submission was part of a press release issued by the ATO on 22 July.
Key points from the submission include the following:
- Persistent and sustained compliance action is required to obtain abusive use of tax heavens.
- Bank secrecy is often a feature of tax havens. However, some countries that are not low-tax jurisdictions have bank secrecy arrangements that may be exploited to conceal income and evade tax because they do not have effective tax information exchange program with other countries.
- The priority for is to deal very firmly with the worst abuses and in particular, promoters and their onshore associates who encourage use of abusive tax haven schemes. International promoters provide specialised accounting, banking and professional trustee services. According to the ATO intelligence, a component of the services provided by promoters is to establish entities or trustees which are not able to be connected to the ultimate or beneficial owner.
- Privacy and secrecy laws in tax havens facilitate tax evasion and impede tax evasion investigations and enforcement efforts. Essentially, the main impediment arises from the difficulty of obtaining basic information that may be indicative of fraud or evasion.
- Whilst the legislative framework of banking and privacy laws governs the operation of financial institutions, trusts and nominee companies, it is useful to recognise the importance of separating the powers between the financial sector, the executive and the judiciary to ensure transparency and effective operation of the regulatory system.
The ATO also presented in the submission strategies and initiatives used to deal with offshore tax evasion. Some of these strategies and initiatives include legislative reform, multi-jurisdiction collaboration, international promoter strategy and mutual assistance requests.
Top
2. Draft legislation on Division 6C released
On 23 July, the Assistant Treasurer and Minister for Competition Policy and Consumer Affairs, the Hon Chris Bowen MP, issued a media release announcing the release of draft legislation to reform Division 6C of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936.
As reported in Editions 6/2008 and 10/2008 of the Tax Bulletin respectively, prior to release of this draft legislation, the Assistant Treasurer had issued a consultation paper in this regard on 22 February 2008 and the Institute lodged a submission with respect to it on 19 March 2008. Since the lodgement of the latter submission, the Institute has been involved in confidential discussions with the Department of Treasury and the Assistant Treasurer’s Office.
Key changes contained in the draft legislation include:
- Clarifying the scope and meaning of investment in land for the purpose of deriving rent;
- Introducing a 25 per cent safe harbour allowance for non-rental, non trading income from investment in land;
- Expanding the range of financial instruments that a managed fund may invest in or trade; and
- Following consultation with industry, providing a further 2 per cent safe harbour allowance at the whole of trust level for non-trading income.
Comments on the draft legislation are due on 14 August and the Institute is considering making a further submission as there are a number of remaining concerns. Members can provide us with comments by e-mailing us at mailto:taxgroup@charteredaccountants.com.au by 1 August.
The legislation is expected to be introduced into Parliament in the 2008 spring sittings.
Top
3. Institute meets with Government Departments on Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme
Following the release of the Green Paper (as reported in Edition 27/2008 of the Tax Bulletin), on Monday 21 July, the Institute's Tax Counsel, Ali Noroozi, along with a number of other stakeholders, participated in a meeting with the ATO and the departments of Treasury and Climate Change in relation to the tax aspects of Australian Carbon Pollution Reduction Scheme.
The Departments of Treasury and Climate Change provided an overview of the Scheme and the preferred position on the taxation treatment of emission permits which is largely set out in Chapter 11 of the Green Paper. Following this, there were some useful discussions. However, more detailed discussion is likely to take place in mid to late August when another such meeting is planned.
Submissions on the Green paper including taxation issues are due on 10 September and the Institute will be lodging a submission. Members' feedback is welcomed by 22 August by e-mailing us at mailto:taxgroup@charteredaccountants.com.au.
Top
4. Meeting with ATO and Treasury to discuss GST issues
On Wednesday 23 July, the Institute had their annual meeting with representatives from Treasury and ATO to discuss GST matters. The Institute was represented by Michael Evans (KPMG), Stephen Baxter (Indirect Tax Consulting Group), Kevin O’Rourke (PwC), Ali Noroozi and Norman Kang of the Institute.
Various items were discussed at the meeting, including:
- Consequences of recent significant litigation cases such as KAP Motors and Brady King
- Application provisions for future amendments to indirect tax law
- ATO approach to GST audits
- Status of the following issues under the new Government:
- Use test relating to residential premises
- Going concern
- Section 38-190(3)
- Division 48- GST Groups
- Division 147
- Vouchers
- Recent press release of GST measures announced but not enacted by the previous government
- Discussion of “in connection with”.
Many of the above issues are now likely to be addressed as part of the review of the legal framework for the administration of the GST, as reported in Edition 27/2008 of the Tax Bulletin. The Institute will be preparing a submission on the issues paper relating to this review and members are encouraged to provide input by emailing us at mailto:taxgroup@charteredaccountants.com.au by 22 August.
Top
5. Institute attends NTLG - Transfer Pricing Sub-group meeting
Anthony Seve (KPMG) and Chris Bowman (Grant Thornton) attended the NTLG – Transfer Subgroup meeting as the Institute’s representatives on 22 July 2008.
Intra-group finance guarantees and loans
The main item on the agenda was the ATO discussion paper on Intra-group finance guarantees and loans, with Deputy Commissioner Jim Killaly, (Case Leadership) present for the discussion.
Some comments from external members of the Sub-group included:
- The issue was one that should be addressed by Treasury rather than by the ATO
- Concern as to the planned retrospective application of the ATO’s proposed approach
- Practical issues associated with taxpayers implementing the ATO’s proposed approach, including:
- Determination of the arm’s length capital structure for a particular taxpayer
- Determining the impact, if any, of implicit credit support provided by a parent company
- Potential for double taxation
- Compliance costs and whether the ATO could develop administrative approaches to enable a large proportion of affected taxpayers to be removed from the need to incur substantial compliance costs.
The ATO acknowledged that the application of the approach proposed in the discussion paper raised many complicated compliance and market issues and they proposed that two working groups be created to look at these. The ATO also advised that it would not be finalising TD 2007/D20 (interaction between thin capitalisation rules and transfer pricing rules) prior to further consideration of the discussion paper.
The Institute is in the process of preparing a submission to the ATO on the discussion paper that we are aiming to complete by mid August. Comments are welcome and can be emailed to mailto:taxgroup@charteredaccountants.com.au by 7 August.
Other
Other items discussed at the meeting included:
- The ATO Transfer Pricing Compliance program and strategy
- Litigation update
- APA program review update
- Customs implications of transfer pricing adjustments – GST issues still being resolved.
- Business Restructures
- OECD developments - The ATO advised that it expected the OECD to issue a series of issues papers on transfer pricing and business restructuring in September/October 2008.
Members can email the tax group if they have questions in relation to the above.
Top
6. Institute’s submission on Inquiry into Schedules 1 and 2 of the Tax Laws Amendment (2008 Measures No. 3) Bill 2008 released
On 15 July, the Senate released submissions on Inquiry into the Provisions of Schedules 1 and 2 of the Tax Laws Amendment (2008 Measures No. 3) Bill 2008. As reported in Edition27/2008 of the Tax Bulletin, on 7 July, the Institute lodged a submission in relation to Schedule 1 (McNeil amendments) and 2 (GST correct a deficiency in GST refund restriction provisions of this Bill. A link to submissions lodged with the Senate on this is provided here.
Top
7. Institute’s submission on Inquiry into the Tax Laws Amendment (2008 Measures No.4) Bill 2008 released
Also, on the same day the Senate released submissions on Inquiry into the Tax Laws Amendment (2008 Measures No.4) Bill 2008. As reported in Edition27/2008 of the Tax Bulletin, on 21 July, the Institute lodged a submission opposing the reversals relating to family trusts in Schedule 2. A link to the submissions lodged is provided here.
Top
8. Joint submission on draft ruling and determinations
The Institute has lodged joint submissions, available on the Institute website, on the following draft Taxation Determinations and Rulings:
TD 2008/D8 - Income tax: when is income tax of a private company a ‘present legal obligation’ for the purposes of the distributable surplus calculation under subsection 109Y(2) of Division 7A of Part III of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936?
TR 2008/D5 - Income tax: meaning of ‘Australian superannuation fund’ in subsection 295 95(2) of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997
GSTR 2008/D2 - Goods and services tax: general law partnerships and the margin scheme
GSTD 2008/D2 - Goods and services tax: is a supply by way of an in specie distribution of an asset that is applied or intended to be applied in an enterprise carried on by a discretionary trust to a beneficiary of the trust made ‘in the course or furtherance of’ the trust’s enterprise?
Top
9. Transfer pricing judgment finalised - Roche Products Pty Limited v Commissioner of Taxation [2008] AATA 639
The Tribunal has handed down its final decision in this matter involving Roche Products Pty Ltd, an Australian subsidiary of Roche of Switzerland, and its dealings with two related parties.
As reported in Edition 12/2008 of the Tax Bulletin, the Tribunal handed down a preliminary judgment in April of this year, inviting further submissions from the parties in case he (the Tribunal President) had misunderstood some of the economic or accounting concepts in reaching the decision.
In summary, for the prescription division, the Commissioner’s decisions were in the most part set aside as excessive and instead appropriate uplifts/adjustments were determined. The Commissioner’s assessments relating to the other divisions, ie the consumer division and the diagnostics division, were set aside as excessive.
The Tribunal ordered that the uplift arrived at by it should be applied to the income years ending 1993 to 1996 and 1998 to 2001, with amended assessments to be issued in the appropriate amounts. This was also to be the case for 2002 and 2003, despite the taxpayer's argument. However, the provisions of s 170(2), namely that the Tribunal’s powers of amendment expire when those of the Commissioner expire, applied so that the assessment for 1997 stood.
Top
10. Commissioner’s decision not to transfer amount to running balance account not reviewable - Command Recruitment Group (Qld) Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2008] AATA 619
The Tribunal has concluded that it lacked the jurisdiction to review a decision of the Commissioner not to allow transfer to the applicant’s running balance account and integrated client account, certain PAYG withholding payments erroneously made to the credit of the integrated client account of a related, but separate, corporation.
More specifically, the Tribunal found that there was no provision in the ITAA 1936 or the Tax Administration Act 1953 allowing an objection to be made against a decision relating to the transfer or crediting of payments to a taxpayer’s running balance account. It followed that the Commissioner’s decision was not an “objection decision” so that section 14ZZA(a) could not apply because the applicant did not have a “reviewable objection decision” in respect of which it could seek review by the Tribunal.
The Tribunal also observed that its conclusion was supported by Taxation Ruling TR 96/12.
Top
11. Decision Impact Statements
The ATO has released decision impact statements (DISs) on:
- Murdoch v Commissioner of Taxation, as reported in Edition 20/2008 of the Tax Bulletin. This Full Federal Court case looked at characterisation of an amount paid by trustees of a trust to a beneficiary entitled to income for life in consequence of a claim made for an amount as recompense for moneys not had as a result of breach of fiduciary duty by the trustees. As stated in the DIS, ‘The view of the Court was that the taxpayer's claim was a claim against the corpus beneficiary for an accounting by him to her of an actual capital profit or gain seen by the Court as having been made by him and to an entitlement to a constructive trust over the assets of the trust estate, with the result that the amount received by the taxpayer was not income’. The ATO is of the view that the decision is of limited application because of the unique facts of the case.
- Drysdale v Commissioner of Taxation, as reported in Edition 18/2008 of the Tax Bulletin. In this case, the Tribunal found that the acquisition of a yacht and associated acquisitions by the applicant were not creditable acquisitions, as the acquisitions were not made in carrying on an enterprise. Rather, the yacht was used either in a private recreational pursuit or hobby and/or purchased without any reasonable expectation of profit or gain. The DIS states that the decision confirms that a taxpayer is required to demonstrate that sufficient indicators of a business exist to establish that activities have been done in the form of a business for the purpose of paragraph 9-20(1)(a) of the GST Act.
Top
12. Class Rulings
CR 2008/49 - Income tax: Demerger of Impedance Cardiology Systems Inc. by ImpediMed Limited
CR 2008/50 - Income tax: Distribution of VISA proceeds by Cuscal Limited via the issuance of a special class of share
Top
13. Product Rulings
PR 2008/59 - Income tax: tax consequences of investing in equities using the Macquarie Geared Equities Investment plus
PR 2008/60 - Income tax: 2009 Willmott Forests Premium Forestry Blend Project
Withdrawals
PR 2007/68W - Withdrawal - Income tax: tax consequences of investing in equities using the Macquarie Geared Equity Investment plus
PR 2008/46W - Withdrawal - Income tax: Curtis Eastern Project
Top
14. ATO Interpretative Decisions
ATO ID 2008/109 - Controlled foreign companies: financial intermediary business
Withdrawals
ATO ID 2001/43 (Withdrawn) - Deductions and expenses: Self Education Expenses (Postgraduate Study Overseas)
ATO ID 2001/49 (Withdrawn) - Nominal Repairs
ATO ID 2001/84 (Withdrawn) - Travel expenses: Combined Purposes
ATO ID 2001/317 (Withdrawn) - Costs incurred for the payment of rates on a vacant block of land
ATO ID 2001/340 (Withdrawn) - Dependent Spouse Tax Offset - prospective spouse residing overseas
ATO ID 2001/410 (Withdrawn) - Rental Property Expenses - GST component
ATO ID 2001/671 (Withdrawn) - Non-income producing property - rates and fencing expenses
ATO ID 2001/796 (Withdrawn) - Deductibility of Rental Property Advertising Expenses
ATO ID 2002/183 (Withdrawn) - Deductibility of consulting fee expenses - rental property
ATO ID 2002/249 (Withdrawn) - Assessability of bonuses received upon termination of a life insurance policy
ATO ID 2002/506 (Withdrawn) - Self-education expenses - Receives tax-free scholarship and employed part-time in field of study
ATO ID 2002/560 (Withdrawn) - Alienation of Personal Services Income -payments to an associate
ATO ID 2002/572 (Withdrawn) - Alienation of Personal Services Income - Losses from rental property
ATO ID 2002/652 (Withdrawn) - Rental Property Expenses - mortgage discharge expenses
ATO ID 2002/702 (Withdrawn) - Retirement income entities: Leasing property to members on non-arms length basis.
ATO ID 2002/777 (Withdrawn) - Deductions and expenses: Investment expenses (Non-profit organisation)
ATO ID 2002/817 (Withdrawn) - Deductibility of interest under a line of credit facility - mixed purpose loans
ATO ID 2002/830 (Withdrawn) - Deductibility of Interest on a Loan Used to Finance a Share Trading Operation
ATO ID 2002/901 (Withdrawn) - Self education expenses: deductibility of meals and accommodation
ATO ID 2002/950 (Withdrawn) - Deductibility of storage expenses - personal items removed from a rental property
ATO ID 2002/1029 (Withdrawn) - Body corporate fees - taxpayer still living in a property that they intend to use as a rental property
ATO ID 2002/1030 (Withdrawn) - Tax-related expenses - penalty not deductible
ATO ID 2002/1097 (Withdrawn) - Cost of obtaining an estimate of the cost of depreciating assets
ATO ID 2003/33 (Withdrawn) - BOTPLS - deductibility of loan repayments
ATO ID 2003/34 (Withdrawn) - BOTPLS - deductibility of course fees
ATO ID 2004/241 (Withdrawn) - Interest deduction: purchase of a motor vehicle costing more than the cost limit for depreciation purposes - 'one third of actual expenses' method
ATO ID 2004/242 (Withdrawn) - Interest deduction: purchase of a motor vehicle costing more than the cost limit for depreciation purposes - log book method
ATO ID 2004/896 (Withdrawn) - Exempt income: scholarship paid to a student enrolled part-time due to personal circumstances
ATO ID 2004/933 (Withdrawn) - Rental property: body corporate levies - special contribution levied for capital expenditure
ATO ID 2004/934 (Withdrawn) - Rental property: body corporate levies - administration fund or general purpose sinking fund
ATO ID 2005/55 (Withdrawn) - Energy Grants (Credits) Scheme: mining - extraction of shale
Top
15. Legislative Instrument
A New Tax System (Commonwealth-State Financial Arrangements) Act 1999 - Determination of the Guaranteed Minimum Amount (20/06/2008) was registered on the Federal Register on 22 July 2008. This Determination specifies the guaranteed minimum amount for the 2007-08 GST year.
The determination and explanatory statement are available here.
Top
16. Recent ATO publications
Booklets and publications
Fuel tax credit eligibility tool - This decision tool is designed to assist you in determining whether the fuel you use in your business may be eligible for fuel tax credits.
eLink 27/08 - Bulletin to inform tax practitioners of the most recent updates to ato.gov.au including a lead article titled 'How to calculate your clients fuel tax credits claim'. Issued on 16 July 2008.
The Australian Business Register (ABR) is just a click or two away - If you save the ABR web address to your favourites you can switch quickly between the Tax Agent Portal and the ABR.
Response to article in The Australian on 22 July 2008 - Response to Susannah Moran's article in The Australian on 22 July 2008 regarding Project Wickenby
Supreme Court hands down $21 million penalty in fuel blending case - The NSW Supreme Court has ordered a NSW south coast company and the estate of its deceased principal to pay nearly $21 million dollars after being convicted of a series of fuel blending offences.
Administration
Tax agent services survey 2008 - The Tax agent services survey 2008 seeks to gain an understanding of tax agent usage of various services and opinion as to how effective they are.
First home saver accounts
First home saver accounts - who is eligible? - Outlines the eligibility criteria, timing and rules for using the first home saver accounts.
First home saver accounts - how you can benefit - Describes the benefits of the first home saver accounts, how to operate the account and how it is used when you want to buy or build a house.
First home saver accounts - what qualifies as a home? - Explains the terms home, ownership and occupancy in relation to first home saver accounts.
First home saver accounts - how do they work? - Information on how the first home saver accounts work.
First home saver accounts - how does the account balance cap work? - Uses case studies to illustrate how the first home saver account balance cap works and the exceptions that may apply.
First home saver accounts - common questions - First home saver accounts offer a simple, tax-effective way of saving for your first home through a combination of government contributions and low taxes. Find out about the conditions applying to these accounts.
First home saver accounts - overview - Provides an overview of the first home saver accounts intitiative including eligibility criteria, how it works and how to set up and use the accounts.
Non-profits
Non-Profit News Service No. 0208 - Helping employees understand the reportable fringe benefits amount on their payment summaries - Jul 2008. Reportable fringe benefits - facts for employees (NAT 2836) has recently been updated. It helps employers explain what reportable fringe benefits amounts are, and what they mean for their employees.
Minutes of meeting
Commissioners Small Business Consultative Group minutes - 2 June 2008 - Draft minutes of the Commissioner's Small Business Consultative Group meeting held on 2 June 2008.
Top
17. OECD Model Tax Convention – update approved
On 17 July 2008, the OECD Council approved the contents of the 2008 Update to the OECD Model Tax Convention.
The contents result primarily from the OECD reports on Improving the Resolution of Tax Treaty Disputes, Revised Commentary on Article 7 (in relation to attribution of profits to permanent establishments), Application and Interpretation of Article 24 (Non-Discrimination), Tax Treaty Issues related to Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) and The Tax Treaty Treatment of Services.
The 2008 Update also includes a number of technical changes on topics such as:
- The concept of “place of effective management”
- The situation of dual-resident persons who are treaty non-residents under the tie-breaker rule
- Certain aspects of the definition of royalties
- Whether days of residence should be taken into account for the purposes of the computation of the 183-day rule.
It is expected that a revised version of the OECD Model Tax Convention, incorporating the contents of the 2008 Update, will be released in September.
More information and access to the various reports mentioned above is available on the OECD website.
Top
18. OECD Report on the Attribution of Profits to Permanent Establishments
Also on 17 July, the final version of the Report on the Attribution of Profits to Permanent Establishments was released. The Report provides guidance on the principles for attributing profits to a permanent establishment under Article 7 of the OECD Model Tax Convention and reflects the results of work undertaken to examine how the principles developed in the OECD’s Transfer Pricing Guidelines for application to separate but associated enterprises should apply in the context of the relationship between a permanent establishment and the rest of the enterprise to which it belongs.
Further details and a copy of the Report are available here.
Top
Chartered Accountants Tax Seminars for Practice
Seminar one - GST, CGT and Income Tax for Property Transactions
Seminar two - Buying and Selling a Business
Throughout August and September in Sydney and Melbourne. Minimise risk and optimise the benefit for your business or your clients with two 3 hour seminars held in Sydney and Melbourne on GST, CGT and Income Tax for property transactions and Buying & Selling a business.
Chartered Accountants New Employees Taxation Workshop
Throughout July and August in Sydney, Brisbane, Melbourne and Perth. This intensive two day workshop will provide new employees with the taxation skills and understanding needed to improve productivity in the early stages of employment.
Chartered Accountants Tax Atlas Series
A reference tool that assists in identifying key issues, understanding of key concepts and provisions. Available now: Tax & Wealth Creation; FBT & Salary Packaging; Small Business CGT Concessions.
Top
Ed. on ATO’s new identification program since July 2008 published in last week’s Tax Bulletin
Please note that the last week’s member input on the ATO’s new identification program was provided by a member in commerce and not a registered tax agent. We have raised the issue with the ATO and there seems to be a new identification program in place since July of this year for non-registered tax agents only. As far as we are aware no details of this change or the reasons for it have been provided to date. We have requested this information and are awaiting a response.
We reiterate that the new identification program applies to non-registered tax agents only. Tax agents are subject to a different proof of identity requirements. The ATO website detailing on proof of identity requirements for registered tax agents can be accessed here.
Top
Help us to improve the bulletin by sharing your tax issues and experiences that might be of interest to other members. Responses should be emailed to taxgroup@charteredaccountants.com.au
Disclaimer
The Institute has created and maintains this tax bulletin as a service to its members and the community. While some of the information provided is about legal issues and legislation, it is not legal advice. The Institute does not expect or invite any person to act or rely on any statement, view or opinion expressed in this bulletin, and readers should make and rely on their own inquiries in making any decisions or giving any advice.
The Institute accepts no responsibility for any errors or omissions contained in this bulletin, and disclaims all warranties with regard to the information at this bulletin, including all implied warranties of merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose. In no event shall the Institute be liable for any loss or damage arising out of or in connection with the use of this bulletin or the information contained in it, including special, indirect or consequential loss or damage, and whether such loss or damage arises in contract, negligence, tort, under statute, or otherwise.
The material provided in this bulletin is protected by copyright. Apart from any use permitted under the Copyright Act 1968, no part of any material may be reproduced or provided to the public or to any person, in any form or by any means, without written permission from the Institute or the relevant copyright owner.
Any information provided to the Institute in connection with this bulletin shall be provided by the submitter and received by the Institute on a non-confidential basis. The Institute shall be free to reproduce, use, disclose and distribute this information to others without limitation.
|